So much for the benefits of their average fourteen years of experience! Certainly no scientific theory would survive such a poor success rate! The institution whose team of astrologers had judged all horoscopes got hits, of which fifty-one were bright and fifty-one were mentally handicapped, so their judgments were, again, no better than tossing a coin.
Tragically, our statistician, Sudhakar Kunte, died in an accident in , and the security he imposed on data storage has so far made it difficult for us to perform further tests, such as whether the astrologers agreed on their judgments, whether they could pick high IQ better than low, and whether the three astrological methods used Nirayan, Sayan, Krishnamurty differed in success rate.
We hope that the access to this data will eventually be possible.
In Clark twenty astrologers averaged 72 percent hits for ten cases of high IQ paired with cerebral palsy, but this famous result could not be replicated by Joseph , where twenty-three astrologers averaged only 53 percent hits for ten cases of high IQ when paired with the severely mentally handicapped. It is also consistent with the few tests of Western astrologers who practice Vedic astrology, for example Dudley Our experiment with twenty-seven Indian astrologers judging forty horoscopes each, and a team of astrologers judging horoscopes, showed that none were able to tell bright children from mentally handicapped children better than chance.
Our results contradict the claims of Indian astrologers and are consistent with the many tests of Western astrologers. In summary, our results are firmly against Indian astrology being considered as a science. The Department of Statistics, Pune University, and the Inter-University Centre for Astronomy and Astrophysics, Pune, provided infrastructural support while this experiment was being conducted. A brief account appeared in Current Science 96 5 , —, My special thanks to Geoffrey Dean of Perth, Western Australia, for providing information on tests of Western astrology as well as giving me a general background of astrology in the West versus the East.
Babylonian omen ideas arrived in India around BC during the Persian occupation, followed, around AD, by Greek astrological ideas based on planets. To these were added new ideas to suit Indian culture. The end result was largely the Indian astrology still in use today, which exists in numerous schools disagreeing over details most schools of astrology, Indian or Western, disagree over details.
The main differences from Western astrology are a preoccupation with reincarnation and karma, use of the sidereal zodiac instead of the tropical zodiac they now differ by nearly one sign due to precession , exclusion of the non-classical planets Uranus, Neptune, and Pluto in favor of the two lunar nodes Rahu and Ketu, use of twenty-seven lunar mansions or nakshatras, and progressively smaller and smaller subdivisions of the signs Stein and Rao Braha , xiii warns that the complexity can be dealt with only by intuition and experience, so Indian astrology cannot be properly learnt from books.
But tests of Western astrologers have found that neither self-rated use of intuition nor experience raise their success rate above chance Dean and Kelly So why should Indian astrologers be any different? At one time Rao ran a computer horoscope service but without predictions. According to ancient Hindu texts, each believer has 8,, rebirths from which they are released only by attaining enlightenment.
At say, fifty years per birth, and no change over time, the allocated rebirths span more than million years, roughly the age of the earliest hominids.
- december 22 horoscope aries or aries?
- Look up or look down??
- sagittarius horoscope week of november 3 2019.
But some come close. For example Rakesh Anand used astrology to make several important decisions in his life, but the results were disastrous. So he prepared horoscopes for twenty-four celebrities and nine personal friends, changed their names, and was able to get astrologers from everywhere in far northern India to predict their life and events. But none succeeded. For example, they predicted no political career from the horoscope of George Bush and no big money from the horoscope of Bill Gates.
For details, visit www.
Can Vedic Astrology Foretell the Future?
The above chapter accused me of venturing into areas I had not investigated and was therefore ignorant of. For example, I had made the supposedly inexcusable mistake of declaring that astrology was not a science. I hope the present investigation can set the record straight. Braha, J. Miami: Hermetician Press. Dean, G. The case for and against astrology. Farha ed. Is astrology relevant to consciousness and psi? Journal of Consciousness Studies 10 6—7 : — Mather, and I.
Stein, editor, Encyclopedia of the Paranormal , Prometheus Books. Dudley, J.
An attempt to predict accidental death with Vedic astrology. Correlation 14 2 : 7— Twenty road deaths vs controls gave 11 hits vs 10 expected by chance. Joseph, R. A Vernon Clark-model experiment distinguishing exceptionally gifted high performance from profoundly retarded low performance children. Journal of Geocosmic Research 1 3 : 55— Premanand, B. Bhatty, and M.
Why Science Says Astrology Lacks Meaning and Evidence
On the other hand, what people should do with that forecast is under their control. Even in the worst-case scenario, one can choose to get rid of harmful habits and find opportunities for the next phase. In Vedic astrology, it means that since the Sun or Moon was in a particular house that has been attributed to a bunch of planets we call Taurus or Virgo, etc.
There is no way that Saturn took a vacation when you were born. If somebody says that Mars in my horoscope brings bad luck. It means that Mars in a certain position will have an adverse effect for a brief time. Remember, everyone has Mars in their horoscope. With due respect, people who criticize astrology have no knowledge of its history.
They, however, continued to practice and develop astrological theories that ensued in astonishing predictions. Astrology is a collection of symbols and metaphors created to help us connect to the world, just like the metaphors found in the different spiritual texts across the world. Astrology, if handled in the right way, can help us to guide us to a bright future.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Astrology as science has proved its worth and helped people of all ages, races, genders, and nationalities, and we can only hope that it gets better in the years to come. Previous — Why you should use Numerology? Related Posts. Previous Article Why you should use Numerology? Scientists feared that Teissier would use the qualification to elevate the status of astrology and further her claim that astrology should be recognised by the Sorbonne as a legitimate area of study.
Internet Sites. Indian University Grants Commission. Understanding Veda.
Related indian astrology and science
Copyright 2019 - All Right Reserved